Can You Sue Home Builders For Construction Defects?

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Although you likely weren't a party to the original building contract, you may have recourse against the contractor hired by the prior owner if you purchase a home with construction flaws. Herein are the answers to your questions:

    • To bring a claim against a builder in VCAT where you may have a right against the builder engaged by the prior owner, you must do so within three years of the date on which the cause of action arose.
    • methods for identifying the appropriate contractor

    The party at fault for shoddy building work should be made to pay for any defects. Problems arise, and they can be a source of anxiety and disappointment. But, keep in mind that these are merely the tip of the iceberg of the building process. The objective is to make whoever is at fault fix the problem. The agreements made between homeowners, contractors, freelancers, and anybody else with a financial stake in the project can often provide light on what went wrong during construction.

    One's responsibilities towards such deficient works constitute legal building liabilities. A defects liability term is typically stipulated in construction contracts. This clause of a contract specifies the contractor's obligation to make necessary alterations or repairs to the work already completed. The maintenance time ends, and the period of defects liability begins. Contracts Specialist's expert construction lawyers can explain everything in language you can comprehend.

    FAQs About Home Builders

    All domestic building contracts have implied warranties that ‘run with the property. That means that whoever is the property owner can claim against the builder if the builder breached one of the implied warranties of the original building contract – for example, if the builder did not follow plans and specifications or did not carry out the works with reasonable care and skill. The relevant law is set out in sections 8 and 9 of the Domestic Building Contracts Act 1995 (Vic). So, for example, to claim against a builder contracted by a previous property owner: 

    • First, you need to try to resolve the dispute with the builder via the Domestic Building Dispute Resolution Victoria (DBDRV) 
    • If the dispute is not resolved at DBDRV, you must file your claim in VCAT before the limitation period expires. 
    • If you file a claim in VCAT, you will need expert evidence to support your claim.  

    Depending on the nature of your claim, the limitation period to file a claim in VCAT is usually ten years from the date your occupancy permit or certificate of the final inspection was issued. However, in some situations, a six-year limitation period applies from the date the contract was breached instead.

    It is your responsibility to make sure you file your application at VCAT within your relevant limitation period. You should seek legal advice as soon as possible if you are unsure if the limitation period has expired or if you think it’s close to expiring.

    You can ask the person who sold you the property to confirm who built your home. For example, if the seller contracted the builder, they could likely tell you the builder and give you a copy of relevant documents. You should confirm the correct identity of the builder by obtaining and reviewing the following documents that will likely list the name of the builder:   

    • Building permit – if one exists.  
    • Domestic building insurance certificate – if one exists. 
    • Domestic building contract – if you can obtain a copy. 

    These documents may be included in the bundle of documents you received when you purchased your home as part of the “section 32 vendors statement” attached to the contract of sale. 

    The point is that the builder is the one who must coordinate the innumerable players and products needed to transform a set of two-dimensional drawings into a finished home. The builder has to make sure that everything happens just when it's supposed to, and that the end result is exactly what the clients envisioned.

    It may seem like a simple part of the overall construction process, but your foundation is the most important part of your entire project. The biggest reason for this is that any mistakes you make in the foundation will only get worse as you go up.

    Building Defects And Its Liabilities

    Claims for construction or renovation flaws must be filed within six (6)years of the project's completion date. State of New South Wales Home Warranty Insurance confirms this. The most frequently raised legal theories concerning construction faults are those of negligence, breach, breach of promise, strict responsibility, fraud, and careless misrepresentation.


    Contractors, subcontractors, and developers all have a duty to use reasonable care, skill, and expertise when working on construction projects for other people. Furthermore, contractors are responsible for the actions of their subcontractors that cause harm to the project.

    Committing a Contract Violation

    Any party involved in the building process might be held liable for damages if a homeowner is dissatisfied with the finished product. This violation occurred because the work wasn't done according to the construction contract's detailed plans and specifications.

    Breach of Warranty

    pexels sora shimazaki 5668481The term "warranty" is commonly used to describe a time-limited written assurance. The homeowner and builder both sign a contract outlining the project's scope and details, and this document serves as the warranty on the home's condition.

    Accountability Restricted to a Minimum

    A homeowner who sues their contractor under strict responsibility doesn't have to provide any evidence of negligence on the part of the contractor in order to win the case. They must, however, show that the contractor were involved in the mass manufacturing of the houses in question, that the houses in question are defective, that losses were incurred as a result of the faults, and that the builder was responsible for the problems.

    Intentional and Careless Lies

    When a building or contractor makes misleading claims about the quality of their work, they are committing fraud. For instance, the contractor had no plan to adhere to the specified design plans and requirements as the project progressed. Negligent misrepresentation also occurs when a builder or contractor presents an unfounded assertion as fact.

    Defects Liability Clauses

    Defect responsibility clauses in a home construction contract may also specify the following:

    • the extent of the problems that need to be fixed by the contractor; the percentage of the contract price that the owner will hold back until the contractor finishes fixing the defects;

    Defects Liability Period

    The "defects and liabilities period" refers to the time frame covered by a new-home warranty. The typical new-home warranty covers defects for thirteen (13) weeks. In some cases, you should consult with your builder for advice on other crucial aspects of the project. The specifics of the time frame covered by a contract are negotiable.

    It is possible to convey your additional problems to the builder via a well-written letter. Be sure to hang onto the duplicate as evidence of your good faith. For a period of six (6) years after construction is finished, the contractor is responsible for making sure there are no severe faults. ...and two (2) years for any other faults.

    Who’s Responsible?

    Determining liability for defective construction or merchandise can be difficult. This is just one example of the various reasons why construction flaws are such common causes of disagreements between clients and service providers. Protracted and expensive litigation is sometimes necessary to resolve a dispute.

    Taking Responsibility

    Products' flaws might not become obvious for a while. After a defective device has been installed, for instance, it may be challenging to determine who is liable for paying for the necessary repairs.

    There are a number of ways in which a construction product could be flawed. When a problem arises during construction, it is the builder's duty to fix it at no extra expense to the homeowner. Nonetheless, the statute of limitations on defects liability may apply.

    The contract with the homeowner, statutory warranties, and defective liability periods mandated by the Australian Consumer Law all contribute to the builder's duty to deliver a habitable and safe dwelling. The Builder shall carry out again and complete the Work in a workmanlike manner, and shall utilise only New Materials in accordance with the Contract and all applicable Specifications and Laws. In the end, this means doing all it takes to deliver a product that meets the needs of the customer.

    The builder, under common law, must also guarantee that the structure is built to a reasonable and secure standard. A builder is not obligated by common law to inspect subcontractors' or suppliers' work for flaws, but he or she is typically expected to do so and bear the costs of rectification before claiming reimbursement from the responsible party.

    If a contractor installs a faulty product, either via carelessness or intent, the contractor will be held responsible. Nonetheless, the builder is not likely to be held accountable for a flaw in a component or substance utilised if the builder might not have been anticipated to know or discover the existence of the problem.

    Your Rights Around Building Defects

    When a client files a claim for defective work during the insurance term, the contractor has to fix the problem. There are times when you need a professional with construction law experience because the claims process has not gone smoothly.

    What Did You Need To Know?

    If your builder is qualified to carry out the work, they should have included statutory warranties in the contract you signed before beginning construction. To put it another way, if you find any defects or incompletions in the work, you have the right to have the builder correct them throughout the warranty period. But, you should be aware that there are strict deadlines that must be met when filing a claim for improper building work to guarantee that you do not lose your right to pursue the builder.

    • The statute of limitations for claims related to construction work that was never started or finished is 12 months from the day the work was supposed to have begun or stopped.
    • Two years from the project's completion date for problems that are not of a structural nature.
    • Six years from the project's completion date for structural problems.

    When you get legal advice from the beginning of a project, you can make sure that you don't miss any important milestones and that your bases are covered.

    What Should I Do If I Am Served With A Payment Claim?

    tingey injury law firm nspj z12lx0 unsplashA party that has been served with a bill shall react within the time frame specified in the applicable contract, but in no more than fifteen business days following the date of service. The schedule of payments must include:

    • Tell us which payment claim it is related to;
    • Indicate how much money the party intends to pay, if anything; and
    • In the event that the amount requested to be paid is less than the amount specified in the payment claim, the response must provide an explanation for the discrepancy, which must include the grounds for withholding payment. To reiterate, an Adjudication Answer can only address the issues raised by the payment schedule.

    During the time frame allowed by the BIF Act, a new budget must be issued with a dispute over the claim's amount. The party that is served with the interim payment may be held responsible for the entire amount requested if they do not respond within the time specified in the claim.

    What If The Respondent Does Not Serve A Payment Schedule Or Pay An Adjudicated Amount?

    If a respondent to a payment claim does not submit a payment schedule, the claimant may:

    • submit an application for adjudication to the Court, or file a petition for judgement against the responder for the claimed sum.

    If a plaintiff goes straight to court for a ruling, the defendant can't file a counterclaim against them or assert a defence based on the construction contract, per the BIF Act.

    An alternative is for the claimant to get a certificate from adjudicator if the respondent is found liable for an adjudication amount but fails to pay the sum by the deadline specified in the adjudication. If you want to take legal action to collect on this debt, you can use the adjudication certificate as evidence in a court of law.

    What Happens After I Give Notice Of A Claim Of Charge?

    The employer must then withhold the sum owed by the general contractor to the contractor. A subcontractor who becomes a secured creditor in this way. If the employer does not pay the subcontractor the agreed upon sum, the employer may be held accountable for the debt.

    If numerous subcontractors file a charge, the landlord may be forced to divide the funds held by them among them. Head contractors are required to notify both their employer and any subcontractors within ten days of receiving notification of a claim of charge.

    • opposes the claim; or accepts responsibility for paying the amount specified in the contractor's notice but challenges the claim in all other respects

    How Can A Contracts Specialist Help You?

    You can trust that the counsel you receive is specific to Sydney construction law because that is all we do. We will review your construction contract, look into any possible breaches, and determine your legal options. Every day, we help clients just like you resolve construction-related disputes, so it's likely that we've seen a situation quite similar to yours before. As such, we will utilise our knowledge and skill to assist you throughout the entire legal procedure.

    Building And Construction

    When it comes to construction and building, our staff is highly regarded.

    What makes us stand out is that we are familiar with the business realities of such construction projects, that we are dedicated to our clients, that we respect their goals, and that we appreciate the commercial perspective while addressing construction concerns. We provide legal counsel in all aspects of building and construction to general contractors, subcontractors, engineers, owners, developers, federal agencies, investors, homeowners, and corporations.

    We provide our customers with an in-depth understanding of the laws and procedures that apply to their situations. Our legal team has extensive experience in:

    • Services related to contract interpretation and legal counsel
    • Discussion on Construction Agreements
    • Disputes During Construction
    • Construction that is both flawed and unfinished.
    • The problems of strata and body corporations
    • Accountability for Errors in the Profession and Carelessness
    • Methods for minimising danger and ensuring quality in construction
    • Constructing Mechanisms for Conciliation
    • Controversies in the Building Industry
    • Fees Paid to Subcontractors
    • Settlement requests and receivables collection

    Some of the main things we specialise on are:

    • Conflicts in Commercial Construction
    • Settlements under the Building and Construction Industry Security Act (Qld)
    • Claims under the Building and Construction Industry Payment and Security Act (NSW)
    • Costs assessed under Section 4 of the Construction Industry Fairness (Payment Security) Act of 2017 (QLD)
    • Disputes over substandard or unfinished work
    • the Queensland Home Warranties Program
    • Payouts from the New South Wales Housing Construction Compensation Fund (HBCF)


    The most crucial information is that a claim must be filed against a builder in VCAT within three years from the date the cause of action arose, and that whoever is at fault for subpar construction work must pay for the repairs. Negligence, breach, breach of contract, strict liability, fraud, and careless misrepresentation are the most commonly cited legal theories in relation to building defects. When working on someone else's construction project, general contractors are liable for the actions of their subcontractors that cause damage to the project, just as subcontractors are liable for the actions of their general contractors. Our skilled construction lawyers at Contracts Expert will explain everything in terms you can understand. Strict responsibility requires the homeowner to prove that the builder was responsible for the defects, that the builder participated in the mass production of the houses at issue, that the homeowners suffered losses as a result of the defects, and that the builder should be held liable for the defects.

    The "defects and liabilities period" of the new-home warranty, the amount of the contract price that the owner will withhold until the contractor finishes fixing the defects, and the scope of the problems that the contractor is responsible for fixing are all examples of things that might be spelt out in a defect responsibility clause in a home construction contract. Additional issues can be communicated to the builder via letter, and for the first six (6) years after construction is complete, the contractor is responsible for ensuring that there are no major faults, and for the next two (2) years, the contractor is responsible for ensuring that there are no other faults. Construction or product defects might make accepting responsibility for repairs challenging, and legal action may be necessary to resolve a dispute. The builder has an obligation to provide a habitable and safe dwelling in accordance with the contract with the homeowner, the statutory warranties, and the faulty liability periods required by the Australian Consumer Law. The builder is responsible for making sure the construction is erected safely and securely, as well as inspecting the work of any subcontractors or suppliers.

    If a customer files a claim for faulty work while the policy is still active, the contractor is obligated to make the necessary repairs. Claims for faulty construction must be submitted within specific timeframes in order to preserve legal recourse against the contractor. Claims linked to uncompleted construction work have a 12-month statute of limitations from the date work was scheduled to begin or end, two years from the date the problem was discovered if it is not structural in character, and six years from the date the problem was discovered if it is structural. Consulting a lawyer at the outset of a project can help ensure that all of the bases are covered and that no critical steps are missed. If a payment demand is issued to me, what should I do?

    A response to a bill must be made no later than fifteen business days after the date of service, or within the time range established under the applicable contract, whichever is shorter. When responding to a payment claim, a party must specify whose payment claim it is addressing, how much money, if any, will be paid, and why the requested payment amount is less than the amount mentioned in the payment claim. In the event that the Respondent does not provide a payment plan, the Claimant may file a petition for judgement against the Respondent in the amount sought. If the respondent is found accountable for an adjudication amount, but fails to pay the sum by the deadline given in the adjudication, the claimant may obtain a certificate from the adjudicator. The adjudication certificate can be used as evidence in a judicial proceeding to recoup the debt.

    Amounts owed by the general contractor to the contractor must be withheld by the employer, and the employer may be held liable for any unpaid amounts owed to the subcontractor. Landlords may be compelled to distribute cash held by many subcontractors in the event of a charge being filed by any number of those contractors. Within ten days of obtaining notice of a claim of charge, general contractors are obligated to inform both their employer and any subcontractors. Because of their familiarity with the commercial reality of construction projects, their dedication to their customers, respect for their aims, and understanding of the commercial perspective while addressing construction difficulties, a Contracts Expert can aid clients in resolving conflicts. Contractors, subcontractors, engineers, owners, developers, government agencies, investors, homeowners, and businesses are just some of the clients we represent. We are experts in cases involving disagreements in the construction industry, commercial construction disputes, claims under the Building and Construction Industry Security Act (Qld), costs assessed under Section 4 of the Construction Industry Fairness (Payment Security) Act 2017 (QLD), disagreements over unfinished or defective work, and HBCF reimbursements.

    Content Summary

    • If you buy a house that has construction faults, you may be able to take legal action against the contractor employed by the previous owner, even if you probably weren't a party to the original building contract.
    • means of picking the best contractor
    • Those responsible for subpar construction work should be required to foot the bill for fixing the problems they caused.
    • Nonetheless, there may be a time limit on claims related to faults.
    • If a customer files a claim for faulty work while the policy is still active, the contractor is obligated to make the necessary repairs.
    • Any claims connected to construction work that was never started or completed have a 12-month statute of limitations, starting on the day that work was scheduled to begin or end, whichever is later.
    • Again, an Adjudication Response can only deal with questions about the payment plan.
    • Within ten days of obtaining notice of a claim of charge, general contractors are obligated to inform both their employer and any subcontractors.
    • disagrees with the claim or agrees to pay the amount shown in the contractor's notice but disputes the rest of it The Role of a Contracts Expert. Since we only focus on construction law in Sydney, you can rest assured that the advice you receive is relevant to your situation.
    • We will investigate any probable breaches of your building contract and advise you of your legal alternatives based on our findings.
    • We represent general contractors, subcontractors, engineers, owners, developers, federal agencies, investors, homeowners, and corporations in all manner of building and construction law matters.
    • We educate our clients thoroughly on the rules and procedures that pertain to their specific cases.
    • Legal advice and contract interpretation services Discussion on Construction Agreements and Disputes that Occur While Building Unfinished or Defective Buildings.
    Scroll to Top